Ah, okay. I'm afraid I have to come down on the side of games in that case (although I'd already voted for 'Main thing is a good story').
'The Hypnotist' is just too linear for my tastes, which would be fine in a story that was written in the third or first person. However, in a story that's written in the second person (which effectively casts the reader as the central character) it just feels unnecessarily restrictive to me.
You might want to read
this, in which Greg Costikyan puts the case for games.