Page 1 of 1

Is my game a finished one or a project?

PostPosted: Thu, 17Jul27 22:44
by GDS
I'm just about to make public a game:
Image

But I really am confused if I should post as project, or a finished game,

Because the game still a WIP, but it's bigger then any other game I finished,
It's like a fished game, with no end, 13 full scenes with lost of parts and animations, but the story still not fully finished,

So what should I do?

EDIT: The HTML5 version is here: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/697085
But Im still working on the thread, may take some time

Re: Is my game a finished one or a project?

PostPosted: Thu, 17Jul27 23:10
by yahoo
I think it depends on what you want to achieve by posting the game. In "Projects", people will typically comment on how to improve parts of the game that you have already completed, as if they're open to improvement.
FWIW, Brad's Erotic Week is in the finished games section, and it's the definitive unfinished game (even though it's fully playable).

Re: Is my game a finished one or a project?

PostPosted: Thu, 17Jul27 23:31
by kexter
I say put it in Projects first, we can move the thread later if the consensus is that it belongs to "All sexy games" (or later if you request it). It can also be beneficial to get some early feedback while it's still in the Projects area so you can fix any unforeseen issues that might surface at the last minute.
By the way, the image you put in the spoiler tag doesn't show up.

Re: Is my game a finished one or a project?

PostPosted: Thu, 17Jul27 23:35
by fleet
If I were you, I'd place it in 'Projects' until you are satisfied that it is completed, and you don't expect or plan to do any additional work on it.

Re: Is my game a finished one or a project?

PostPosted: Fri, 17Jul28 18:30
by GDS
yahoo wrote:I think it depends on what you want to achieve by posting the game. In "Projects", people will typically comment on how to improve parts of the game that you have already completed, as if they're open to improvement.
FWIW, Brad's Erotic Week is in the finished games section, and it's the definitive unfinished game (even though it's fully playable).

Yeap that's the game that made me confused...



kexter wrote:I say put it in Projects first, we can move the thread later if the consensus is that it belongs to "All sexy games" (or later if you request it). It can also be beneficial to get some early feedback while it's still in the Projects area so you can fix any unforeseen issues that might surface at the last minute.
By the way, the image you put in the spoiler tag doesn't show up.

I fixed the image, guess Gdrive doesn't like hot-linked images

Re: Is my game a finished one or a project?

PostPosted: Fri, 17Jul28 19:16
by Dole
In your picture you must delete the side name and it is not allowed to use it here.

A lot of Games/Projects are deleted here because the people used the side name.

So I would change it quick or this thread is not long living.

Re: Is my game a finished one or a project?

PostPosted: Fri, 17Jul28 20:13
by GDS
Dole wrote:In your picture you must delete the side name and it is not allowed to use it here.

A lot of Games/Projects are deleted here because the people used the side name.

So I would change it quick or this thread is not long living.

You mean the Pat**** name?
Pretty sure I cannot make propaganda and ask for donations, but I checked my oldest games and they have the logo since last year and its fine,

I don't think its needed to edit the whole main menu of the game(Pause menu too) to post the pictures here, is it?

Re: Is my game a finished one or a project?

PostPosted: Fri, 17Jul28 21:38
by Skelaturi
Really? Mhm time to delete some posts then be right back. Ask Shark, explain it and ask what to do. It might just be that unlike other people where we wanted that gone. You used to be/ still are a bit more active on this forum. It's not that your only posting for your own game. Then go away. But ask what Shark has to say i could be wrong about it

Re: Is my game a finished one or a project?

PostPosted: Fri, 17Jul28 23:15
by GDS
Skelaturi wrote:Really? Mhm time to delete some posts then be right back. Ask Shark, explain it and ask what to do. It might just be that unlike other people where we wanted that gone. You used to be/ still are a bit more active on this forum. It's not that your only posting for your own game. Then go away. But ask what Shark has to say i could be wrong about it

When I starting to use the P-site I asked, Because I was scared to lose my work, and got this answer: Its ok, as long I don't ask for donations, or juts come here for propaganda. it was about the time they put that warning as a stick.

P.S. This thread can be closed, I just posted the game as project for now,

Re: Is my game a finished one or a project?

PostPosted: Sat, 17Jul29 00:26
by kexter
Thread locked on request of GDS, continue the discussion over at the game's topic.